The Good Listener’s Toolkit for Good Dads

Good Dads Communicators: A couple sit side-by-side on a couch, both talking and gesturing with their hands

The Good Listener’s Toolkit for Good Dads

Have we been listening all wrong?

This is a question Good Dads Founder and Executive Director Dr. Jennifer L. Baker has been pondering with her clients for quite some time. Dr. Baker, who is also a licensed clinical psychologist and marriage and family therapist, says problems arise when couples think they are listening but are really just waiting for their turn to talk.

When people say they are listening, she says, they are really using the word “listening” as a synonym for “hearing.” That’s pretty different from listening to understand.

When we listen to understand, we are paying attention to much more than just the words coming from someone’s mouth, she said. We are also paying attention to the context of the words — like, why are you saying this now? We’re considering things like how fast or slow someone is speaking, their cadence, tone and body language. We are giving someone our full attention, making eye contact, our bodies turned toward the speaker.

Listen like a therapist

To truly listen, Dr. Baker says, is to give someone your full attention and try to understand where they are coming from. Are you listening as though you’re on the defensive, or are you listening like a therapist?

When Dr. Baker sees couples in therapy, she leans on the ideas and research of Stephen R. Covey, whose very popular 1989 book “The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People” contends that, when we listen, we inadvertently filter the speaker’s words through our own experiences and lenses to reach a conclusion about what the speaker means.

Filters can prevent productive conversations between partners — like when you are being very tired, emotional, or distracted. We can only interpret the words of others through our own personal lens, which is a composite of cultural upbringing, family of origin, mood and experiences.

“All of these things prevent you from being able to truly tune into where the other person is coming from,” Dr. Baker said. “It’s good to be aware that we all have our own biases and preconceived ideas. They are always there, and the best thing we can do is to be aware of them.”

But what does this look like in practice? Here are eight tools you can add to your toolkit to be a better listener – PsyD approved!

Reflective listening

“Some people don’t really know what they think until they say it,” Dr. Baker said. For that reason, the best listeners know to reflect statements back to the speaker. For example: “Well, it sounds like you want me know _____.”

Reflective listening essentially means you are feeding back the same words you heard. This gives the speaker the chance to say: Yes, that’s right, or no, that’s not what I meant.

“If you are truly listening to understand, you have to be able to respond in a way that demonstrates that you got it,” Dr. Baker said.

(Nudge, Nudge: You can practice reflective listening yourself at Good Dads’ next Facilitator Training Camp, where you’ll learn everything you need to know to effectively lead a Good Dads class.)

Mimesis

Mimesis is a fancy psychology term that means mimicking someone’s communication style, like their tempo and word choice, Dr. Baker said. It’s a little like “matching someone’s energy.” Matching can build rapport and help the speaker feel understood.

For example, if your animated and energetic teenager is loudly telling you about what happened in gym class today, you might match that by putting some energy into your own tone, too.

Make it clear that your opinion isn’t the only one

Occasionally Dr. Baker’s clients ask her what she thinks about a given situation. She needs to be careful here, because even though she is a professional, she’s not immune to those individual filters that Covey wrote about in 7 Habits. She is intentional to say, “Well, since you asked me, here’s where I’m coming from … but of course, if you walk down the street and ask someone else, they might tell you something very different.”

Dads can use this technique when they’re asked for advice, too. This tool works best for emotional or interpersonal issues that are delicate or nuanced. You might not need to do this for something simple like who should pick up your daughter from school or what to have for dinner tonight.

Validate intense feelings

One of Dr. Baker’s most powerful tools for being a good listener in therapy is affirming that someone’s intense emotions are real. She’ll tell her clients, “It makes sense to me that you are upset.”

“You aren’t saying you agree with the feeling,” she clarified, “but you say, ‘Given all that you’re facing, these feelings make sense. Things are intense.’”

As a good listener, it’s important to be able to “sit with” someone’s very strong emotions, she said, and to let the other person know that they are still acceptable.

This is especially true for young children, who are learning what to do with big emotions. Dads need to be a stable presence and reassure children that you’re not going to “freak out” because of their intense emotions, she said.

This skill takes practice, according to Dr. Baker. “We might have our own feelings about what someone says, but we must be very careful not to project our own feelings onto our loved one.”

Bonus tip for fathers of small kids: Be aware that very young people don’t have the same vocabulary as grown-ups. This means they can’t always put words to their feelings.

Say what you want

Good listeners recognize the value of XYZ statements, a communication tool that helps resolve conflicts without playing the “blame game.” The structure looks like this:

  • In X situation …
  • … When you do Y …
  • … It makes me feel Z.

If you say, “Why do you always leave your clothes on the floor? You’re such a slob! I always have to pick up your socks,” things are probably not going to go well. Addressing a conflict this way puts the other person on the defensive. Instead of hearing the frustration about dirty clothes, the listener is more likely to think up all the instances where they aren’t a slob — and all the reasons why you’re wrong.

Instead, rephrase to specify what you want instead of what you don’t want.

“It’s always easier to see more of something than less of something,” Dr. Baker said.

For example: “I really appreciate it when you put your clothes in the hamper and when we work together to hang the shirts in the closet. It makes the house feel so tidy.”

  • X situation: When things are tidy…
  • Y action: You put clothes in the hamper…
  • Z feeling: I appreciate us working together.

See the difference? In the second statement, we’re saying exactly what we want. The recipient hears exactly what the other would like to have happen, Dr. Baker said.

The internal monologue goes from, “Hey! That’s unfair! I’m not a slob!” to: “When I do this, my partner feels like we’re working as a team.”

Sometimes, being heard is better than being right

Dr. Baker gave this scenario to illustrate her point:

You come from a long day at work, and right when you get in the door your wife just goes off about how your 15-year-old son is driving her crazy. “He’s been so disrespectful lately; I can’t believe he talks to me like that … His room is a pigsty! … And don’t get me started on his grade in Algebra … He’s just so irresponsible.”

Even though you are probably very tired, it would be wise to listen to your wife – even if (in your opinion) her view is a little warped.

You may be thinking: I was just like that when I was 15, and I turned out alright … It’s not that big of a deal; she should really get off his case … It’s his room, why does it matter if it’s a wreck?

This is a very important place to listen. Just listen first! Don’t jump into problem-solving mode. It may be more crucial at this moment to help your wife feel heard.

(Very observant readers will also notice that this scenario is a perfect place to use another tool we’ve talked about: validating intense feelings.)

Listen first, and only after things have calmed down can you begin to approach how to deal with this problem.

Accept that you cannot always control distractions, but minimize all that you can

Dr. Baker said that it’s helpful to recognize that distraction-filled events are often catalysts for arguments or fights. Recognizing this pattern takes practice, but when we do, we are more likely to make better listening choices. Here’s an example:

The event: Your credit card statement comes in the mail when you’re rushing out the door, running late to your daughter’s soccer practice.

The argument: You and your fiancée spend the whole ride to soccer practice arguing (and sometimes yelling) about the mortgage, groceries, utilities, and even the cost of your daughter’s soccer jerseys. You end up being very late to practice, which is fodder for another big argument on the drive home.

Where did things go wrong?

Rewinding back to the event, Dr. Baker said: “Maybe that’s not the best time to have that discussion. Certain upsetting events aren’t always the best time.” In other words, the arrival of the bill is the catalyst for the argument – but in an environment full of distractions, it is very unlikely that a conversation about bills goes well.

Dr. Baker’s advice is to find a time when you can increase the likelihood that you are heard.

We do not do our best thinking, listening and communicating when we are focused on other tasks, when we are very hungry or tired, or when there are competing priorities, she said. Perhaps a better way to approach the conversation about the credit card bill would be to wait until everyone is home from soccer practice, after dinner, and after your daughter is in bed for the night.

Sometimes, we have some power over our distractions. For example, an emotional conversation might not be the best time to open Instagram. But we can’t always control distractions. You know this if you and your partner have tried to start a tough talk only to be interrupted by a crying toddler!

Give your partner the benefit of the doubt

A famous example of giving someone the benefit of the doubt is the hypothetical of the speeding driver. When you spot a car going 20-MPH over the speed limit, driving erratically and weaving through lanes, which thought are you more likely to have?

  1. Wow, this guy’s a real jerk! Does he think he’s the main character?
  2. Wow, maybe this guy’s wife just went into labor and he’s trying to get to the hospital ASAP!

Most of us would probably pick #1. It’s natural to sometimes assume the worst, but the good news is you can train your brain to give people the benefit of the doubt.

“In general, this means having a little humility,” Dr. Baker said.

When you make a negative interpretation about your partner’s intent, you are playing make-believe that you can read minds. The reality is that you don’t know everything!

Dr. Baker’s advice? Think carefully about the story you are telling yourself. “There could be a number of stories you could be telling yourself,” she said.

The scenario: You made dinner last night, and your partner promised to do the dishes. But when you come downstairs the next morning, all the dirty dishes are still piled in the sink and on the countertops.

Negative interpretations:

  • She’s lazy
  • She doesn’t care about having a messy kitchen or attracting ants
  • She is punishing you for something you must have done to upset her
  • She knows you hate dirty dishes in the sink, so she left them on purpose to tick you off

Instead, when you give your partner the benefit of the doubt, you make the deliberate choice to NOT assume that your partner is messed up, crazy, stupid, lazy, or making you mad on purpose.

  • Maybe she meant to and completely forgot
  • Maybe she started doing the dishes and discovered we’re out of dish soap, or maybe the dishwasher isn’t working
  • Maybe something urgent came up last night that you don’t know about

The best next step is to bring it up with your partner so you can get to be bottom of the issue – instead of just continuing to make assumptions. Nothing gets done when we live in a world of maybes!

A caveat: Giving your partner the benefit of the doubt doesn’t mean you purposely overlook your partner acting badly. Please don’t take this advice to mean that making excuses for bad behavior (especially violent, neglectful actions) is the right route.

In the next blog

We’ve talked about so many ways dads can be great listeners to their partners and their children. Next time, we’re going to expand on what we’ve learned here by discussing a common miss-fire in the way couples argue.

If you’ve minimized distractions, matched their energy, validated their feelings and are STILL having arguments that explode into full-blown fights, you might be trying to SOLVE the problem too quickly. More to explore in the next blog: When problem-solving doesn’t solve the problem.

About the Author

Diana Dudenhoeffer is the director of communications at Good Dads. She works to maintain Good Dads’ online and print presence. Diana is a graduate of Missouri State University; she studied journalism, sustainability and documentary storytelling.

Tags
Sort by Topic:

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo.

Related Posts